Open your website next to three of your competitors and cover the logos. Can you tell which one is yours? If you’ve caught yourself asking why do all websites look the same now, you’re not imagining it. They do. And if yours is one of them, it’s probably costing you enquiries.

Why do all websites look the same? Because they’re built the same way

This started well before AI.

Researchers at Indiana University compared thousands of websites across more than a decade. They found that sites had been getting more alike since around 2010, and layout was where it showed most: the differences between one site’s layout and the next dropped by more than 30%.

It wasn’t copying. Everyone had started building with the same kits, the same templates and the same handful of trends, so everyone ended up in the same place.

For a founder, that matters more than it sounds. Your website is often the first time someone meets your business. If it looks like the last three they opened, they’ve got nothing to remember you by.

Why do all AI websites look the same?

Then AI turned up and made it quicker.

Ask an AI tool for a website and you’ll have one by the end of the afternoon. It’ll look fine. It’ll also look like the last one that tool made, and the one before that. These tools learn from the websites that already exist, so what they hand back is the most common version of a website.

That’s our view, not a study. But we look at a lot of websites, and we’d bet you’ve noticed it too.

Looking fine used to take time and money. Now it takes an afternoon, so looking fine doesn’t set you apart from anyone.

Different colours, same website

Here’s the part people miss. AI websites share one layout and one style. What changes from one to the next is the images, the fonts and the colours.

You know the layout. Big headline. Three boxes underneath. A row of testimonials. A button.

So when someone tells you a site has been customised, ask what actually changed.

  • Bullsh*t: “we customised it”, when the only things that moved were the colours, the font and the photos.
  • Not bullsh*t: a page laid out around what your customer needs to know first.

A new colour palette doesn’t make a website yours. Your competitor can pick new colours too, and then you’re back where you started.

Why do some websites work but not others?

Put two websites side by side that sell the same thing at a similar price. One gets enquiries and the other doesn’t. The difference usually isn’t how good they look.

The one that works is clear about who it’s for, and it could only belong to that business. Its words, its photos and the order of its pages come from the business, not from a template.

That’s less common than you’d think. Ipsos and JKR tested more than 5,000 brand assets, things like logos, colours and slogans, and found that only 15% were truly distinctive. Most brands are easy to mix up with someone else’s before a website is even involved.

Clear beats clever here. A visitor should be able to tell what you do, who it’s for and what to do next without hunting for it. If they have to work it out, they’ll close the tab and open the next one.

You can see what that looks like on a real site in our Paddington Works case study.

When a visitor can’t tell you apart, they choose on price, or they go with whoever replies first. That’s what looking the same costs you.

It’s also how we judge our own work: by enquiries and sales, not by how a site looks in a screenshot.

What to do next

You can check all of this yourself, today.

  1. Do the logo test. Put your homepage next to three competitors and cover the logos. If you can’t pick yours out, your customers can’t either.
  2. Read your headline out loud. If a competitor could say the same thing, rewrite it until they couldn’t.
  3. Look at the order of your homepage. If it runs headline, three boxes, testimonials, button, so does everyone else’s. Start from what your customer needs to know first and build the page around that.
  4. Swap the stock photos. Use real ones of you, your team or your work.
  5. Check the next step is obvious. Pick the one thing you want a visitor to do and make sure every page points to it.

If you’d like to see how we go about it, here’s how we build websites.